India Makes Progress on GST Implementation

22 Aug 2014

DELHI – India moved closer towards implementing a Goods and Services Tax (GST) with the conclusion of the latest meeting by the Empowered Committee of State Finance Ministers this Wednesday.

While numerous hurdles remain central and state Finance Ministers agreed on several important items that are expected to speed up the implementation process:
  • Two-part levy: Central GST and State GST;
  • Common threshold for the levy of GST: All businesses with annual turnover of more than Rs 10 lakh (US$16480) for general states and Rs 5 lakh (US$8240) for special-category and north-eastern states;
  • Harmonize GST exemption lists nationwide: 96 items exempted by States and 243 items by the Center.
The proposed GST will replace several existing taxes including the central level excise tax and service tax and state level VAT entertainment tax lottery tax and electricity duty with one single tax thus facilitating the consolidation of a single market across the country and allowing for greater supply chain efficiency and economies of scale.
The Central Sales Tax (CST) which is levied by the Center on inter-state movement of goods but collected by the states has been a major obstacle towards moving the GST proposal forward as some states are concerned about the loss of revenue they would face with the phasing out of the CST.
More industrialized states such as Gujarat Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu which derive 70 to 80 percent of their revenue from state taxes are most concerned about the potential change in tax base with the GST. By shifting taxation from production to consumption industrialized states which currently export most of their products to other states around the nation will face significant losses in tax revenue since the levies will instead go to states where the products are sold.
Prior to Wednesday’s meeting Finance Minister Arun Jaitley had assured states that the Center would compensate their loss in CST revenue of about Rs. 34000 crore (about US$5.6 billion) over a three-year period appeasing some of the concerns.
Full implementation of GST could raise India’s GDP growth by 0.9 to 1.7 percent according to the National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER).
However although Jaitley had committed to resolve all outstanding issues by the end of the year challenges remain before the GST can be realized.
Differences remain over the degree of control between states and the Center over central GST. Below the Rs 1.5 crore limit the Center wants to keep legal control and give states administrative control but states are asking for both. Above the limit dual-control is agreed upon.
States are also pushing for high-tax products such as petroleum alcohol and tobacco out of the GST purview.
Some are also concerned that the proposed GST structure will infringe on states’ financial autonomy by removing a large portion of their own revenue source.
A new GST Constitutional Amendment Bill will be drafted for the winter session of Parliament to replace the current one which was first introduced in 2011. To pass the bill must secure votes from two-thirds of lawmakers in both houses of parliament and half of the 29 states.
Asia Briefing Ltd. is a subsidiary of Dezan Shira & Associates. Dezan Shira is a specialist foreign direct investment practice providing corporate establishment business advisory tax advisory and compliance accounting payroll due diligence and financial review services to multinationals investing in China Hong Kong India Vietnam Singapore and the rest of ASEAN. For further information please email or visit
Stay up to date with the latest business and investment trends in Asia by subscribing to our complimentary update service featuring news commentary and regulatory insight.
Published in: India Briefing , August 22, 2014